| Class of | Name | College | Swimming/Diving |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | Haley French Krahn | St. Cate's University | Swimming |
| 2014 | Amber Armstrong | St. Cloud State University | Diving |
| 2015 | Hannah Baratz | Emory University | Swimming |
| 2015 | Kallyn Barkey | Arizona State University | Swimming |
| 2015 | Michelle Campeau | Princeton University | Swimming |
| 2015 | Shavonne Chen | St Louis University | Swimming |
| 2015 | Maggie Ericson | St Louis University | Swimming |
| 2015 | Roberta Lanzino | Wheaton College | Swimming |
| 2017 | Anna Cook | University of Rochester, NY | Swimming |
| 2017 | Kasey Ericson | St Thomas University | Swimming |
| 2017 | Lindsey Turner | St Louis University | Swimming |
| 2017 | Ella Thompson | American University | Swimming |
| 2018 | Bella Lichen | Dartmouth College | Diving |
| 2018 | Madie DeJong | Stevens College | Swimming |
| 2019 | Edie Newman | Tulane University | Swimming |
| 2020 | Aleia Johnson | Carleton College | Swimming |
| 2020 | Ella Rowley | Luther College | Diving |